Pillow Covers Vs. Throw Pillows – Do You Pick A Side?

When we purchased our new build, we set the goal that in one year we’d save enough to renovate the backyard. We had a series of setbacks that year, including being involved in a car accident that totaled our SUV. Luckily no one was seriously injured but we did have to purchase a new car so there went our savings. Fast forward a year later, we decided to finally tackle the backyard by taking out a home equity loan. Since we did not have enough equity in the house, this was essentially a second mortgage at a higher interest rate. Last month I reached out to our mortgage broker and it turns out, based on the current interest rate, we are finally able to refinance our primary mortgage to now include that second mortgage, saving us close to $500/month! Talk about serious savings! In life, there will always be hurdles that change your plans but things have a way of working themselves out. If my story resonates with any of you, I encourage you to talk to a mortgage broker. It’s important to know your options. Moving on to the topic at hand!

Who doesn’t love throw pillows, am I right?! They’re a quick and fun way to transform a space, adding color, contrast, texture, and character. I’ve been curious about this question for some time now and was inspired to write this when I saw the most adorable pillow post from @jr.h0mes. So the question I have is this, are you a pillow cover lover or a throw pillow hoarder? Let me explain, do you prefer to buy pillow inserts and just replace the pillow covers or would you much rather purchase new throw pillows where the insert and cover cannot be separated?

Maybe I’ve been hiding under a rock but up until recently, I wasn’t aware that simply purchasing pillow covers was even an option. When I wanted to switch up my pillow color or style, I bought new throw pillows. These, of course, were the ones without zippers, so I’m proudly going to own it and admit that I was once a throw pillow hoarder. I had a pillow closet and I would rotate throw pillows based on the season. However, now that I’m aware of my options, I have to say I’m a huge fan of simply replacing the pillow covers. Anyone who knows me, knows I’m a planner, an organizer and a firm believer in lists. That being said, the decision to switch to pillow covers was made after weighing the pros and cons of both options.

This post contains affiliate links and I will earn a small commission if you make a purchase using them. Your support is greatly appreciated as it helps with the blog site maintenance.

Product Link

throw pillows – pros

The best thing about purchasing throw pillows is their availability. On any given day you could drive to your nearest Target, Home Goods or any other home decor store and grab some new pillows. If you’re someone like me who appreciates instant gratification, then this might be the option for you. In addition to being easily accessible, these pillows are also pretty darn affordable. For instance, depending on the specific size, you can purchase a throw pillow from Target for as little as $15. At that price, I wouldn’t be upset if these pillows got ruined by my girls, Hubby or house guests.

Product Link

throw pillows – cons

On the downside, throw pillows can take up a lot of space, hence my previous pillow closet. If your home already doesn’t include adequate storage, then finding places for your extra pillows will require some creativity and resourcefulness. Suddenly your living room couch and bedrooms have an unhealthy amount of throw pillows, or maybe your closets or kitchen cupboards. No judgment on my part because I’ve seen it and I may or may not have done some of these things. Also, a throw pillow without a zipper could pose a challenge if it got dirty. They’re usually not machine washable and you’ll likely have to spot clean and hope that does the trick.

pillow covers – pros

Pillow covers require much less space, making storage easy peasy. Instead of having a pillow closet, I now have a pillow drawer and that’s an amazing feeling. Dirty pillow covers can also be easily removed and spot cleaned or hand washed, making them more salvageable. If they are beyond redemption, they can be traded out for new covers, leaving your pillow inserts unharmed. Pillow covers come in many great styles and fabrics that I haven’t seen available with regular throw pillows. Mud cloth, for example, is an extremely popular pillow cover fabric that offers great texture and cool geometric patterns and designs.

Pillow covers – cons

Purchasing pillow covers can get pricy. The size, fabric and particular brand will definitely affect how much you pay. I’m not the most patient person and unfortunately, I haven’t had much success in finding pillow covers in stores. The ones I’ve seen and loved have all been online. Since pillow covers are not as readily available as throw pillows, instant gratification isn’t as easily achieved. Depending on where you purchase your pillow covers, shipping time will vary and so will the return policy. Switching to pillow covers will also require some initial set up, i.e. pillow inserts which will vary in price depending on the size and pillow filling you prefer.

Putting pen to paper and creating my pros and cons lists for both pillow options has truly allowed me to make the best decision that suits our home and lifestyle. I love the designs and styles available to me with pillow covers. I also love that pillow covers are space-saving and although I have to purchase them online, so far, I’ve only purchased from Amazon which allows me 2-day shipping as a prime member. I also make it a habit to purchase pillow covers in sets, as much as possible, because it usually works out being a better cost value.

I strongly dislike paying full price for things and I’m sure many of you can agree with me on this. That being said, I’m okay waiting for items to go on sale before making a purchase. For example, many of the pillow covers I’ve recently purchased were the Woven Nook brand and it was just my luck that Amazon was offering 15% off all their pillow covers!

If any of you, my friends, are trying to make a decision between throw pillows and pillow covers, then I hope you find value in my little list.

I’d love for you guys to join in on the conversation! Comment below and let me know where you stand, throw pillows or pillow covers? Where are some of your favorite stores or websites to purchase pillows?

Aminah Chung

8 Replies to “Pillow Covers Vs. Throw Pillows – Do You Pick A Side?”

  1. “Suddenly your living room couch and bedrooms have an unhealthy amount of throw pillows”

    #Guilty! 🤣

    I need to come to terms with throw pillow covers, they make so much more sense. That instant gratification just gets me every time I walk into Home Goods. The texture, the fluffy ness, the colors – I just love the opened ended options in front of me when I wonder those isles.

    I’m pretty sure I don’t have anymore closet space, so I really need to come to terms with just covers!

    • For all the reasons you mentioned Renee, I can understand why you chose throw pillows! I just grew tired of the pillow piles and really had no more space for them. Just to test the waters, I suggest maybe purchasing a 2-4 pack of pillow inserts and a 2-4 pack of pillow covers. The Woven Nook collection on Amazon is pretty fantastic! Most of the pillow covers featured here are that brand and I’ve been thrilled with them. Plus, they’re currently 15% off so not a bad time to switch things up!

  2. I do prefer pillow covers, but I still purchase the ones with the zipper. I will say that some pillows do not have the best inserts though. Great post. So informative!

  3. Thanks for this reassurance. I always like to purchase pillow covers because they’re not too bulky to store. I love this post. Big fan and I will check out the link❤️.

  4. Aminah I am loving this blog. I have ordered those pillow covers because they are gorgeous. I love every detail that you use to describe the importance of purchasing covers instead of buying pillows and how cost effective and space saving it can be. Thanks for sharing my friend.

    • Oh Malisa I’m so happy to hear that! I hope you’ll like them as much as I do! Thanks for taking the time to read my little blog and for supporting me!

Leave a Reply

* Required fields. Your email address will not be published or sold to any third parties.